Construction of Judicial Unification in the Era of Intelligent Justice: A Pathway to Enhance Judicial Credibility through the Mechanism of Same Judgment for Similar Cases

• 영문명: 智能司法时代的裁判统一性建构：基于类案同判机制的公信力提升路径
• 발행기관: ACADEMIC FRONTIERS PUBLISHING GROUP(AFP)
• 저자명: ZHOU Zhongshan
• 간행물 정보: 『Journal of Chinese Legal Studies (JCLS)』Vol.2 No.3, 24~34쪽, 전체 11쪽
• 주제분류: 인문학 > 역사학
• 파일형태: PDF
• 발행일자: 2025.03.31

국문 초록

In the era of rapid development of intelligent justice, constructing the unity of judicial adjudication has become increasingly critical. The unity of adjudication is not only related to judicial fairness but also constitutes the core element for enhancing judicial credibility. The mechanism of “same judgment for similar cases” serves as a pivotal path to achieve this unity, whose importance is self-evident. However, realizing true judicial unity is fraught with profound contradictions. These manifest in the tension between technological empowerment and judicial norms, the structural contradictions within the judicial management system, and the cognitive gaps within the legal community, all of which to some extent constrain the realization of adjudicative unity. To address these contradictions, it is necessary to explore a credibility-oriented collaborative governance approach, typified by innovating adjudicative rule-making mechanisms, strengthening the modernization of judicial capabilities, and optimizing social participation and supervision mechanisms. In summary, the construction of adjudicative unity in the era of intelligent justice requires fully leveraging the advantages of artificial intelligence while emphasizing the principal status of judges, striving to find the optimal balance between efficiency and fairness.

영문 초록

在智能司法蓬勃发展的当下，构建裁判统一性这一课题愈发关键。裁判统一性不仅关乎司法公正，更是提升司法公信力的核心要素。类案同判机制作为实现裁判统一性的关键路径，其重要性不言而喻。要实现真正的裁判统一性并非易事，其中存在着诸多深层矛盾。具体表现在技术赋能与司法规律之间存在着一定的张力，司法管理体制的结构性矛盾和法律共同体内部的认知鸿沟也在一定程度上制约了裁判统一性的实现。针对这些矛盾，需要探索出公信力导向的协同治理路径，典型的如创新裁判规则供给机制、加强司法能力现代化建设和优化社会参与监督机制。综上说述，智能司法时代的裁判统一性建构需要既充分发挥人工智能技术的优势又强调法官的主体地位，努力在效率与公正之间找到最佳的平衡点。

목차

1 理论结构：裁判统一性与司法公信力的共生关系

2 现实图景：司法大数据支撑下的实践转型

3 制度梗阻：影响裁判统一性的深层矛盾

4 体系重构：公信力导向的协同治理路径

5 结语

参考文献

키워드

Intelligent Justice Judicial Unification Similar Case System Enhancing Judicial Credibility Judicial Big Data 智能司法 裁判统一性 类案同判机制 公信力提升 司法大数据