독수과실의 원리 보론(補論)

• 영문명: The“FruitofPoisonousTree”DoctrineRevisited
• 발행기관: 한국형사판례연구회
• 저자명: 조국(Kuk Cho)
• 간행물 정보: 『형사판례연구』형사판례연구 제23권, 617~650쪽, 전체 34쪽
• 주제분류: 법학 > 법학
• 파일형태: PDF
• 발행일자: 2015.06.30

영문 초록

On November 15, 2007 the Korean Supreme Court made a landmark decision to exclude illegally obtained physical evidence. In 2007 the National Assembly revised the Criminal Procedure Code to stipulate Article 308-2 for the exclusion of illegally obtained evidence, which is effective as of January 1, 2008. Since then, the Supreme Court has made a series of decisions whether to exclude the derivative evidence by applying the “fruit of poisonous tree” doctrine. This Article critically reviews four Supreme Court decisions regarding the “fruit of poisonous tree” doctrine. The issue of the first case is whether to exclude the succeeding blood test obtained upon the defendant’s request besides the breath analyzer test after illegal “voluntary accompaniment.” The issue of the second case is whether to exclude the following urine test obtained upon a judicial warrant in addition to the urine test obtained by illegal arrest. The issue of the third is whether to include physical evidence obtained by the following search of defendant’s home and his confession in police station even if police officer obtained the defendant’s personal information by the violation of the Act for Real Name Financial Transaction and Confidentiality. The issue of the fourth case is whether to exclude physical evidence obtained in the defendant’s home besides his incriminatory statements obtained without giving the Miranda warnings.

목차

[대상판결] 대법원 2013.3.14. 선고 2010도2094 판결

대법원 2013.3.14. 선고 2012도13611 판결

대법원 2013.3.28. 선고 2012도13607 판결

대법원 2009.3.12. 선고 2008도11437 판결

Ⅰ. 들어가는 말

Ⅱ. 불법체포와 2차 증거(혈액)―대법원 2013.3.14. 선고 2010도 2094 판결

Ⅲ. 불법체포와 2차 증거(소변) ―대법원 2013.3.14. 선고 2012도13611 판결

Ⅳ. 영장주의 위반 금융거래정보 수집과 2차 증거(물적 증거와 자백) ―대법원 2013.3.28. 선고 2012도13607 판결

Ⅴ. 진술거부권 불고지와 2차 증거 ―대법원 2009.3.12. 선고 2008도11437 판결

Ⅵ. 맺음말

키워드

독수과실 파생증거 미란다 불법체포 증거동의 poisonous tree derivative evidence illegal arrest warrant Miranda